A federal appeals court has handed Kalshi a major victory, ruling that New Jersey regulators cannot interfere with the company’s sports‑linked contracts.
The decision, issued by the US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, came in a 2‑1 vote and confirmed that oversight of Kalshi’s markets falls solely under the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC).
By leaning on the Commodity Exchange Act and its definition of swaps, the panel made clear that state gambling commissions have no authority over these event contracts. Judge David J. Porter, writing for the majority, described the ruling as the first appellate case to draw a line between state enforcement of gaming laws and federal regulation of event‑based trading.
The dispute dates back to 2025, when New Jersey’s Division of Gaming Enforcement ordered Kalshi to halt operations, claiming its contracts tied to sports and elections amounted to unauthorized betting.
Kalshi rejected that view, pointing to its registration as a Designated Contract Market and its supervision by the CFTC. While a similar argument was recently dismissed in Nevada, the Third Circuit sided with Kalshi here, reinforcing the company’s position that its products are federally regulated and beyond state reach.
Massive decision in prediction market/state war
Kalshi’s win in the Third Circuit marks a turning point in its battles with state regulators. The company has faced mixed outcomes across the country, securing injunctions in Tennessee but running into setbacks in Nevada and Maryland.
What it lacked until now was an appellate precedent, and this ruling provides exactly that, a decision it can carry into ongoing disputes.
A parallel case is already moving through another federal appeals court involving Maryland. If that court reaches a different conclusion, the split could trigger Supreme Court review. The federal government’s stance has also shifted, with the Department of Justice recently taking steps to limit state enforcement against federally regulated exchanges.
The Third Circuit’s ruling fits neatly into that approach, reinforcing the idea that prediction markets fall under a national regulatory jurisdiction.
“We profoundly disagree with today’s decision allowing certain companies to offer sports gambling in our States without following the careful gaming rules that everyone else follows,” New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport said in a statement. “We’ll continue standing with our colleagues fighting off similar challenges in their States, and we’re evaluating all options in our case.”
Source: NEXT.io



for early access to the latest igaming videos!

and get the latest igaming news first!




