The tension increases in Chile due to the implementation of the Supreme Court order about blocking online betting platforms throughout the country. Major telecommunications companies such as Claro, Entel, GTD, Telefónica, WOM, and VTR have confirmed that they fully comply with the ruling, but the industry warns that such platforms continue to operate simply by circumventing the restrictions with minimal technical changes.
Chile Telcos, the association that represents the sector, has so far issued a communiqué confirming that they have complied with the court order. According to its president, Alfie Ulloa, all providers implemented the required blocks. Simultaneously, however, he stated a key caveat: service providers cannot manage traffic based on content, origin, or destination unless specifically ordered by the courts or administrative authorities:
This structural limitation, Ulloa explained, leaves significant loopholes. “Betting sites can change their URLs and remain operational, and there are other access methods that escape the control of Internet providers”, he clarified. Among these alternatives are the use of Virtual Private Networks (VPNs) and independent DNS systems offered by third-party content providers.
Thus, even though telecommunications firms have formally complied with requirements, the online sports-betting platforms have continued to operate, demonstrating issues related to the enforceability of digital restrictions within an open, globalized internet environment.
Follow-up by the Judiciary and Questions of Effectiveness
Concerns over the effectiveness of the block trace back to mid-November, when the Santiago Court of Appeals asked Internet providers to confirm compliance with the Supreme Court ruling. That decision had accepted a legal protection request filed by Lotería de Concepción, arguing that online betting houses operate illegitimately in Chile.
But such an order rapidly turned out to be difficult to carry out technically. Blocking a domain or URL, in practice, is a short-term solution since operators can easily circumvent this block by changing domain names or diverting traffic to other digital paths.
Government Acknowledges Enforcement Limitations
Chile’s Undersecretary of Telecommunications, Claudio Araya, candidly admitted that blocking measures ordered in the country were inefficient. In an interview with Radio Cooperativa, he said that the kind of blocking available at the network level in Chile is “relatively easy to bypass”, given how domain names work.
He said there were “virtually infinite” combinations for domain names; this would always allow operators to adapt. In practice, for every blocked domain, another one can be activated in nearly real time. The result is an enforcement environment akin to “digital whack-a-mole“, where for every move, there’s a countermove by the operators.
Araya also said the judiciary perhaps did not get enough technological advice before the ruling came out. “They could have consulted more to obtain the necessary technical support”, he commented, noting that judges possess legal, not technological, expertise.
Toward a More Effective Long-Term Solution: Regulation
Araya emphasized that the real sustainable solution would be through a regulatory framework for online gaming, given the impossibility of current technical means to enforce the ruling effectively. The proposal for such legislation is currently under debate in the Chilean Senate.
“Regulating does not mean prohibiting“, Araya said. “It means making sure that all participants operate under the same rules, and that is vital.”
A regulated environment would establish clear obligations, control mechanisms, and oversight capacities that go far beyond the limited impact of DNS or URL blocking.
A Turning Point for Chile’s Online Gaming Landscape
Chile is at a crossroads today. The Supreme Court decision also showed that the traditional approaches to legal decisions on digital ecosystems can be readily adapted by platforms, and that users can easily find their way around such restrictions. As telecommunications companies comply with their duties and the state recognizes its technical limitations, comprehensive regulation rather than attempts at a total ban seems increasingly the way ahead.
This debate, now in the Senate, will perhaps ultimately define how Chile approaches the governance of digital gaming: a balance of consumer protection, technological realities, and the growth of an increasingly global online betting market.
Source: YogoNet



for early access to the latest igaming videos!

and get the latest igaming news first!




