A noteworthy ruling has come from the Court of Justice of Rio Grande do Sul (TJRS), in which the gambling operator is compelled to exclude a gambler suffering from compulsive gambling disorder, failing which the operator would be liable for payment of a fine. This ruling came through the result of the monocratic ruling of Appellate Judge Sérgio Fusquine Gonçalves of the 19th Civil Chamber.
This case throws light on the increasing involvement of the judiciary in dealing with social and consumer protection concerns arising from the increasing online betting activities in Brazil.
The Case: Allegations of Pathological Gambling and Financial Losses
The plaintiff filed a declaratory action to seek the nullity of bets, together with claims for material and moral damages, against two betting site operators. As per the case file, the plaintiff stated he developed ludopathy, also referred to as pathological gambling, which was diagnosed by a healthcare professional, owing to his compulsive betting activities, resulting in losses in excess of R$129,000.
He stated that the defendant companies did not follow the policies on gambling established through the enactment of Law No. 14,790/2023 and Ordinance SPA/MF No. 1,231/2024. Moreover, he stated that the websites did not point out his compulsive play but urged him to continue playing through the use of bonuses as well as promotions through notifications.
Among the requested orders was the request for the deletion of his accounts on the platforms and the issuance of an order for the blocking of financial transactions in relation to online betting by the Central Bank of Brazil. These orders were denied by the trial court judge, and as such, an appeal was filed.
Gambling Disorder as a Serious Psychiatric Condition
Judge Gonçalves, in assessing the appeal, made it clear that ludopathy is a serious psychiatric disease recognized by WHO as a condition causing serious impairment in the capacity to control the gambling behavior. The judge was critical of the lower court’s suggestion for the appellant to take advantage of the applications for self-exclusion available in betting companies.
As the judgment states, “the suggestion by the court of first instance that the appellant use self-exclusion mechanisms disregards the clinical reality of the disease, as requiring a ludopath to exclude himself is equivalent to asking a chemical dependent to stop consuming the substance by his own will.” The statement underscores the court’s view that compulsive gambling cannot be treated as a matter of simple personal choice.
Duties of Betting Operators Under Brazilian Law
Additionally, the appeals judge argued that the wagering operators have the legal obligation to supervise the behavior of their players and take measures if signs of problematic or compulsive behavior are distinguished. All of this is clearly established within the existing legislation of Brazil regarding wagering.
On this reasoning, the court required that the claimant be barred from access to these platforms, appreciating the need for court intervention in this case in view of the dignity and health of these consumers in particular. However, this ruling makes it apparent that operators can be held liable for more than simply supplying a service, which in this case was online gambling facilities.
Limits on the Role of the Central Bank
While granting the exclusion request, the court rejected the claimant’s demand that the Central Bank block betting-related financial transactions. Judge Gonçalves held that such a measure would exceed the legal authority of the Central Bank, whose mandate is macroeconomic regulation rather than individualized monitoring of consumer transactions.
In fact, according to the ruling, “the creation and maintenance of a system for monitoring and blocking individualized financial transactions, with the purpose of identifying payments specifically destined for online betting platforms and proactively blocking them for a particular individual, do not fall within the legal or regulatory attributions of the Central Bank.”
This is a significant decision in the evolving online gambling regulatory environment in Brazil. It underlines the fact that responsible gambling is no longer an act of free will but a legal obligation that can be enforced by the courts in case of gambling sites failing to safeguard the interests of gamblers.
Source: BNL Data



for early access to the latest igaming videos!

and get the latest igaming news first!




